Mary Poppins Returns review
I’m Mary Poppins Y’All!
Now with that overused reference out of the way, Mary Poppins is practically perfect in every way. It was the first Disney movie to be nominated for Best Picture technically the first movie with animation to be nominated too (Beauty and the Beast was the first fully animated movie to be nominated). They literally made a movie about the author. The story is pretty simple. A nanny named Mary Poppins comes to take care of the Banks children. If you think this is too similar to the first one, yes it is. After my family watched this my brother said that he thought Mary Poppins Returns was Mary Poppins 2.0 and I kind of agree with him. The movie at times feels like a retread of the original. It has similar beats like making a chore fun, going to an animated world, meeting one of Mary Poppins “relatives”,
Emily Blunt is practically perfect as Mary Poppins. She has the same strict but also charming performance as Julie Andrews. Of course you can’t beat the original actress Emily is still a great replacement for Julie. My Mom is a huge fan of the Broadway show Hamilton so she was excited to see Lin-Manuel Miranda as Jack. Jack is very likable and has the same charm and energy as Dick Van Dyke’s Bert. Both leads work wonderfully with each other. The rest of the cast is good including two well done cameos by Dick Van Dyke and Angela Lansbury. However there is one that doesn’t work and that’s the villain. Why did this have to have a villain? His motivations for taking the Bank’s house is never explained and comes off as like some kids movie villain from the 90s.
I got more excited for Mary Poppins Returns when they confirmed that there would be a scene with 2d animation just like in the original. If you know me, I love 2d animation (why can’t we get more 2d animated movies nowadays?). The Royal Doulton Bowl scene is definitely one of the highlights of the movie. The animation is wonderful, the textures are impressive and the live action characters look like there in the scene. Mary Poppins is known for having great songs and the sequel managed to make great songs too. My favorite songs have to be the opening song (Underneath the) Lovely London Sky and Trip a Little Light Fantastic both ironically sung by Lin-Manuel Miranda. The songs capture the same energy as the songs from the original. It also helps that Richard M. Sherman one of the original song writers worked on this movie as a music consultant
Is Mary Poppins Returns better than the first one? No but let’s face it, why should we top something that was great to begin with. I heard somewhere that Mary Poppins Returns feels like seeing an old friend and I believe that too. Mary Poppins Returns is a nice welcome back into the whimsical world of the practically perfect nanny Mary Poppins.
Verdict:
+ Emily Blunt
+ Lin-Manuel Miranda
+ Royal Doulton Bowl
+ Songs
– A retread
– A villain
Score: A-