The Lion King review
I’m going to be honest here and say that like Nostalgia Critic I do find The Lion King overrated even as a kid. I also agree that the lesson about confronting your past even though Simba didn’t actually kill Mufasa feels very mixed. So now with this remake I was discouraged because unlike Beauty and the Beast and Aladdin, The Lion King was an original story (come at me Kimba fans). I guess it makes sense to have Jon Favreau direct this since he also did the 2016 remake of The Jungle Book. However due to it being more realistic, the characters just don’t have the same emotional facial expressions they had in the original.
The biggest problem to me is that this movie is pretty much a shot by shot remake. Every scene plays off exactly like from 1994 with some added fluff like a scene with a mouse is traveling around pride lands before being caught by Scar. The Jungle Book at least changed the structure of story to make it feel like its own movie. All the songs sound exactly the same from the original except Be Prepared though it doesn’t sound that good. At least in Beauty and the Beast and Aladdin the songs did sound different enough to tell them apart while here it’s like listening to karaoke but with the voices. Also Hans Zimmer’s wonderful score is pretty much unchanged too. It just doesn’t have the same heart it did in 1994.
The casting is honestly the only good thing about this movie. Actors such as Seth Rogan and Billy Eichner feel like good choices to play Timon and Pumba. Hearing James Earl Jones reprise his role was also nice too. However the only one that didn’t feel right was Chiwetel Ejofor as Scar. The original Scar was malicious, manipulative, and cunning, here he seems too bombastic and Shakespearian. Why didn’t they just get Jeremy Irons back? I heard has was surprised that he wasn’t asked to reprise his role as this great Disney villain.
I guess the only other good thing about The Lion King was a funny reference to Beauty and the Beast near the end of the movie. 2019’s The Lion King feels like Disney has two agendas. One was to try to capture the same magic of 1994 for a new generation and the other is to just get money. It’s managing to succeed in one but unfortunately the wrong one. This was a lifeless and unnecessary remake that recycles more than Disney movies directed by Wolfgang Reitherman.
Verdict:
+ Voice cast
– Chiwetel Ejiofor as Scar
– Songs and music
– No heart
– Shot by shot
Score: D